HoloDex vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App
Pick HoloDex if you need Android support, multiple card games, or AI condition insights. Pick Card Value Scanner: TCG App if you use an iPhone and want Pokémon pricing with PSA, CGC and BGS values, eBay sold listings, and free core scanning.
HoloDex vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App at a glance
| Feature | HoloDex | Card Value Scanner: TCG App |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free download. Subscriptions shown from $4.99 per week to $12.99 per month, with annual options from $24.99 to $49.99. Pricing varies. | Free download. Paid features include unlimited collection size, the full graded price ladder, all eBay sold comparisons, price alerts, AI pre-grades and CSV or JSON export. |
| Free tier | 35 free scans. | Core scanning, card matching, raw market value, and PSA, CGC and BGS graded values are free. |
| Games | Pokémon, One Piece, Disney Lorcana, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic, Dragon Ball Super, Digimon, Gundam, Union Arena, Riftbound, and Star Wars: Unlimited. | The app covers Pokémon, Disney Lorcana and One Piece. The website price guide also covers Disney Lorcana and One Piece. |
| How cards are added | Camera scanning. Manual search-to-add, bulk scanning. | Photo identification by name, set, number, and rarity. Multi-card scanning keeps a running session total, and cards can also be entered by hand. |
| Graded prices | Market prices for graded variants. Separate PSA, CGC. | PSA, CGC and BGS graded values, plus PSA, CGC and BGS graded values in the free tier. |
| Sold listings | Recent sales, market history, and price trends. | eBay sold listings, plus TCGplayer and Cardmarket raw prices. |
| Platforms | iOS and Android. The website has product information. | iPhone only, with no Android app. The website has a free price guide and limited free photo scans. |
| App Store rating | 4.8/5 from 22,362 ratings, with figures varying by storefront and date. | 4.1 out of 5 (9 ratings) |
Who HoloDex suits best
HoloDex is the stronger choice for collectors who use Android or manage several trading card games. Its game list extends well beyond Pokémon to Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, Disney Lorcana, Digimon, Gundam, and others. Camera identification, collection tools, portfolios, duplicates, wishlists, price trends, and recent sales place scanning and organization in one mobile app.
It also suits users who want automated condition feedback. Its AI analysis looks for whitening, centering, and surface wear. This is an extra tool rather than authentication or a guaranteed grade. HoloDex recognizes raw, foil, holographic, and graded variants.
Where Card Value Scanner differs
Card Value Scanner has a narrower focus. The iPhone app centers on Pokémon and identifies the card name, set, collector number, and rarity from a photo. Free core features include matching, raw market value, and PSA, CGC and BGS graded values. Pricing draws on TCGplayer for the United States and Cardmarket for Europe, while eBay sold listings provide additional comparisons.
Its clearest advantage is the detail around Pokémon pricing. Users can review PSA, CGC and BGS values, eBay sold listings, a price chart, and a collection total. Paid tools add unlimited collection size, the full graded price ladder, all eBay sold comparisons, price alerts, AI pre-grades and CSV or JSON export. The tradeoff is platform support: it is iPhone and iPad only and has no Android app. It is not a grading or authentication service.
What users complain about
The most common HoloDex complaints concern paywalls and the 35-scan free allowance. Users also criticize subscription pricing and report mismatched values for certain card variants. Database gaps can affect some sets and non-English cards. These issues do not mean every scan is wrong, but collectors should verify the exact set, variant, language, and condition before relying on a value.
AI grading also receives mixed feedback. Some users say repeated scans of the same card can produce different results, and that the condition selected by the user can influence the grade too much. Collection complaints include no CSV export, limited set-based tracking, and little camera control. HoloDex remains stronger for Android and broad game support, but detailed collectors may miss those controls.
Best HoloDex alternatives
- Card Value Scanner: TCG App: best for iPhone users who want Pokémon scans with PSA, CGC and BGS values and eBay sold listings. Its free core covers card matching and basic values, while paid tools add batch scanning, reports, longer history, and CSV export.
- TCGplayer: best for collectors who want prices tied directly to a large trading card marketplace. It shows TCGplayer Market Price, Listed Median, and Most Recent Sale across Pokémon and other supported games.
- PriceCharting: best for collectors tracking cards alongside video games and other collectibles. It combines price guides, historical sales, collections, wishlists, and deal alerts across several collectible categories.
- Collectr: best for portfolio tracking across raw, graded, and sealed products. It focuses on cataloging collections, monitoring total value, and analyzing price movement on iOS and Android.
- PokeDATA: best for Pokémon collectors who need purchase, sale, and profit or loss tracking. It tracks cards and sealed products with price history, population history, sales volume, alerts, and market comparisons.
Other comparisons: CollX vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App, Ludex vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App, Pokellector vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App. All of them are listed on the Pokémon card app comparison hub.
Sources
- getholodex.com/
- app.getholodex.com/
- apps.apple.com/us/app/holodex-tcg-scan-collect/id6747442689
- play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.getholodex.app&hl=en_US
- appinsider.io/apps/holodex-tcg-scan-collect-6747442689
- mwm.ai/apps/holodex-tcg-scan-collect/6747442689
- appshunter.io/ios/app/holodex-tcg-scan-and-collect/id6747442689/reviews
- apptracker.ai/app/6747442689
Frequently asked questions
How much does HoloDex cost?
HoloDex is free to download and includes 35 free scans. Storefront subscription options have ranged from $4.99 per week to $12.99 per month, with annual plans from $24.99 to $49.99. Prices can differ by region, platform, date, or promotion, so the offer shown inside the app may vary.
Can HoloDex be used for free?
Yes. The app includes 35 free scans before additional scanning requires a paid plan. Exact free limits for collection size, price lookups, portfolios, wishlists. Reviews indicate that some functions sit behind a paywall, so free use may be best for a limited trial.
Does HoloDex work on Android?
Yes. HoloDex has native apps for both Android and iOS. This makes it a better fit than iPhone-only scanners for Android collectors. Its website describes the service, but a separate full-featured browser collection manager is not established, so mobile users should expect the apps to be the main experience.
What card games does HoloDex support?
HoloDex supports Pokémon, One Piece, Disney Lorcana, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic: The Gathering, Dragon Ball Super, Digimon, Gundam, Union Arena, Riftbound, and Star Wars: Unlimited. That broad catalog is one of its main advantages over Pokémon-focused alternatives, especially for collectors who keep several games in one portfolio.
Is HoloDex AI grading reliable?
Treat it as a condition estimate, not an official grade. The analysis checks visible issues such as whitening, centering, and surface wear. Users have reported different outcomes when rescanning the same card and say their selected condition can influence the result. Authentication and professional grading still require a qualified grading service.
What are the best HoloDex alternatives?
The right alternative depends on the task. TCGplayer suits marketplace pricing, PriceCharting covers cards and other collectibles, Collectr emphasizes raw, graded, and sealed portfolios, and PokeDATA offers detailed Pokémon profit and loss tools. For iPhone users focused on Pokémon, another option combines photo matching, PSA, CGC and BGS values, and eBay sold listings.
Try the scanner on your own cards
Free on the App Store. Scan a card and compare the result with any app on this page.