Collectr vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App
Pick Collectr if you collect several trading card games, sealed products or graded cards, or need an Android app. Pick Card Value Scanner: TCG App if you use an iPhone and want a Pokémon-focused scanner with raw prices, PSA, CGC and BGS values and eBay sold listings.
Collectr vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App at a glance
| Feature | Collectr | Card Value Scanner: TCG App |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Collectr PRO costs $7.99/month or $59.99/year on iOS. | Free to download. |
| Free tier | Restricted scanning. One review reports 30 scans per day. | Core scanning, card matching, raw market value and PSA, CGC and BGS graded values are free. |
| Games | 25+ trading card games, including Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Disney Lorcana and One Piece. | The app covers Pokémon, Disney Lorcana and One Piece. The website also covers Disney Lorcana and One Piece. |
| How cards are added | Camera scanning, manual search and collection-management tools. | Photo identification by name, set, number and rarity. Multi-card scanning keeps a running session total, and cards can also be entered by hand. |
| Graded prices | General graded-card values and price history. Separate PSA, CGC. | PSA, CGC and BGS graded values. |
| Sold listings | Not published | eBay sold listings. |
| Platforms | iOS and Android. A public website is available. | iPhone only, with no Android app. The website offers a price guide and limited free photo scans. |
| App Store rating | 4.9/5 from 64,000 ratings. | 4.1 out of 5 (9 ratings) |
Who Collectr suits best
Collectr is the stronger choice for collectors who keep cards from several games in one portfolio. It supports more than 25 trading card games, including Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Disney Lorcana and One Piece. It also tracks raw, graded and sealed products. That broader catalog makes it better suited to mixed collections than an app centered on Pokémon.
Collectr also suits people who need both iOS and Android access. Its PRO plan adds unlimited scanning, unlimited portfolios, advanced filters, exports and detailed pricing history. The large App Store rating base may matter to users who prefer an established app. Collectors should note that individual marketplace sold listings are not part of the stated feature set.
Where Card Value Scanner differs
Card Value Scanner has a narrower focus. Its iPhone app identifies Pokémon cards from photos and returns the name, set, number and rarity. Free features include core scans, matching, raw market value and PSA, CGC and BGS graded values. Raw pricing comes from TCGplayer for the US market and Cardmarket for Europe, while graded pricing covers PSA, CGC and BGS values.
The clearest difference is access to eBay sold listings alongside a price chart and collection total. Paid tools add unlimited collection size, the full graded price ladder, all eBay sold comparisons, price alerts, AI pre-grades and CSV or JSON export. The website also has free guides for Pokémon, Disney Lorcana and One Piece, plus limited web photo scans. Collectr is stronger for game coverage and Android support.
What users complain about
The most repeated Collectr complaint concerns free scanning limits. One review reports a limit of 30 scans per day. Users also object to subscription cost and prompts to upgrade. These concerns matter most when entering a large collection, since unlimited scans and portfolios require the PRO membership.
Pricing quality is another recurring concern. User summaries mention outdated, inaccurate or inconsistent market values, including localized pricing issues. Any portfolio estimate should be treated as a reference rather than a guaranteed sale amount. Card Value Scanner addresses a different need by showing eBay sold listings, but it is limited to iPhone and does not offer an Android app.
Best Collectr alternatives
- Card Value Scanner: TCG App: best for iPhone users who want Pokémon photo scanning with raw prices, PSA, CGC and BGS values and eBay sold listings. Its core scan and value tools are free, while paid features add batch scanning, reports and CSV export.
- TCGplayer: best for collectors who want marketplace pricing and saved collection lists. It shows TCGplayer Market Price, Listed Median and Most Recent Sale across games sold on its marketplace.
- PriceCharting: best for collectors who track cards alongside video games, comics, coins and LEGO. It offers price guides, historical sales, collections, wishlists and deal alerts on iOS, Android and the web.
- PokeDATA: best for Pokémon collectors who need profit and loss tracking and detailed market comparisons. It tracks cards and sealed products using data from eBay, TCGplayer, Cardmarket, auction houses and grading categories.
- Pokellector: best for Pokémon collectors focused on set checklists and completion. It provides card browsing, collection progress, want lists, card images and estimated values on web, iOS and Android.
Other comparisons: Pokedata vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App, Pokellector vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App, PriceCharting vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App. All of them are listed on the Pokémon card app comparison hub.
Sources
- play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.collectrinc.collectr&hl=en_US
- apps.apple.com/us/app/collectr-tcg-collector-app/id1603892248?see-all=reviews&pl
- getcollectr.com/pro
- apptracker.ai/app/1603892248
- appinsider.io/apps/collectr-tcg-collector-app-1603892248
- mwm.ai/apps/collectr-tcg-collector-app/1603892248
- unstar.app/app/1603892248?platform=ios&country=gb
Frequently asked questions
How much is Collectr PRO per month?
Collectr PRO costs $7.99 per month on iOS. The annual option costs $59.99. PRO includes unlimited scanning, unlimited portfolios, advanced filters, exports and more detailed pricing history.
Can Collectr be used without paying?
Yes. Collectr has a free version, but scanning is restricted. One review reports 30 scans per day, although Collectr does not state that allowance on its PRO pricing page. Exact free limits for portfolios, exports, saved searches, tracked cards.
Does Collectr support sealed Pokémon products?
Yes. Collectr tracks raw cards, graded cards and sealed products. It also shows collection values and price movements. Its broad support extends beyond Pokémon to more than 25 trading card games, which makes it useful for collectors with mixed sealed and single-card portfolios.
Can Collectr show individual completed marketplace sales?
Collectr provides market values and detailed price history for raw and graded cards. Collectors who need specific sale records can consider an option that displays eBay sold listings or TCGplayer's Most Recent Sale.
What is a good Collectr alternative for Android?
TCGplayer, PriceCharting, PokeDATA and Pokellector all offer Android options. The best choice depends on the task. TCGplayer emphasizes marketplace prices, PriceCharting covers several collectible categories, PokeDATA provides detailed Pokémon portfolio tools, and Pokellector focuses on Pokémon set completion.
Is Collectr only for Pokémon cards?
No. Collectr supports more than 25 trading card games. Named examples include Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Disney Lorcana, One Piece, Flesh and Blood, Digimon and Pokémon. It is a broader portfolio manager rather than a Pokémon-only scanner.
Try the scanner on your own cards
Free on the App Store. Scan a card and compare the result with any app on this page.