Pokellector vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App
Pick Pokellector for set checklists, want lists and collection tracking across web, iOS and Android. Pick Card Value Scanner: TCG App on iPhone when photo identification, PSA, CGC and BGS values, price charts and eBay sold listings matter more.
Pokellector vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App at a glance
| Feature | Pokellector | Card Value Scanner: TCG App |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free download with Pokellector Plus and Pro subscriptions. Effective U.S. | Free download. Paid features include unlimited collection size, the full graded price ladder, all eBay sold comparisons, price alerts, AI pre-grades and CSV or JSON export. |
| Free tier | Not published | Core scanning, card matching, raw market value and PSA, CGC and BGS graded values are free. |
| Games | Pokémon TCG, including English and Japanese sets. | The app covers Pokémon, Disney Lorcana and One Piece. The website price guide also covers Disney Lorcana and One Piece. |
| How cards are added | Browse set lists and add cards manually. A scanner is advertised. | Identify cards from photos by name, set, number and rarity. Higher-volume batch scanning is paid. |
| Graded prices | Not published | PSA, CGC and BGS graded values. |
| Sold listings | Not published | eBay sold listings. |
| Platforms | Web, iOS and Android. | iPhone app and website. No Android app. |
| App Store rating | 4.7 out of 5 from 3.5K ratings. | 4.1 out of 5 (9 ratings) |
Who Pokellector suits best
Pokellector suits collectors who organize Pokémon cards around sets. Its checklists, card images, collection progress and want lists make it useful for working toward set completion. English and Japanese set coverage also helps collectors with mixed binders. The web, iOS and Android options make the same general service accessible across more devices than an iPhone-only app.
It is also a practical choice for collectors who prefer browsing a database instead of relying entirely on a camera. Cards can be identified through set names, symbols and checklist pages, then added to a collection. Users commonly praise its simple interface and clean progress tracking. Its 4.7 App Store rating from 3.5K ratings gives it a much longer public rating history.
Where Card Value Scanner differs
Card Value Scanner centers the workflow on a card photo. It identifies the name, set, collector number and rarity, then shows raw pricing from TCGplayer for the United States and Cardmarket for Europe. It also includes PSA, CGC and BGS values, eBay sold listings, a price chart and a collection total. These details make it better suited to pricing individual cards before a trade or sale.
The free tier includes core scanning, card matching, raw market value and PSA, CGC and BGS graded values. Paid features add unlimited collection size, the full graded price ladder, all eBay sold comparisons, price alerts, AI pre-grades and CSV or JSON export. The main limitation is platform support. The app is available only for iPhone, with no Android app. Its website offers a price guide and limited free photo scans, but it is not a grading or authentication service.
What users complain about
No single Pokellector complaint can be established from its rating totals alone. The clearest practical concern is uncertainty around some features. The app advertises card scanning, but descriptions also discuss scanning PTCGO QR codes. Full camera recognition for ordinary physical cards is unclear. Exact free limits, pricing methodology, update frequency and condition handling are also unspecified.
Collectors focused on resale data may find Pokellector less complete than a dedicated pricing tool. It displays estimated card and set values, but grade-specific PSA, CGC or BGS prices are unclear. Historical sold listings are also not part of the stated feature set. On the other hand, Card Value Scanner has no Android app and a shorter App Store rating history, so Pokellector remains stronger for platform access and established collection tracking.
Best Pokellector alternatives
- Card Value Scanner: TCG App: best for iPhone users who want photo identification with raw prices, PSA, CGC and BGS values and eBay sold listings. It covers Pokémon, Lorcana and One Piece and includes free core scanning, but it does not offer an Android app.
- TCGplayer: best for collectors who want marketplace pricing across several trading card games. It supports Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, Lorcana and other games while showing Market Price, Listed Median and Most Recent Sale.
- PriceCharting: best for collectors who want historical sale data across cards and other collectibles. It covers trading cards, video games, comics, coins, LEGO and related collectibles on the web, iOS and Android.
- Collectr: best for portfolio tracking for raw, graded and sealed products. Its iOS and Android apps track collection values and price movements across several trading card categories.
- PokeDATA: best for Pokémon collectors who need profit and loss tracking, alerts and market comparisons. It tracks cards and sealed products using data from marketplaces, auction houses and multiple grading categories.
Other comparisons: HoloDex vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App, CollX vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App, Pokedata vs Card Value Scanner: TCG App. All of them are listed on the Pokémon card app comparison hub.
Sources
- pokellector.com/
- play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=air.com.pokellector.mobile
- apps.apple.com/us/app/pokellector-card-collector/id600580227?see-all=reviews&pla
- apps.apple.com/mx/app/pokellector-card-collector/id600580227?l=en-GB
- cardbase.io/en/research/best-tcg-collector-apps
Frequently asked questions
Is Pokellector free to use?
Pokellector is free to download, and its App Store page includes Pokellector Plus and Pro in-app subscriptions. Exact free limits for cards, scans, sets or collection entries are unclear. The storefront displays quarterly and yearly figures, but the currency and effective U.S. prices cannot be determined from those figures.
Does Pokellector scan physical Pokémon cards?
Pokellector advertises a Pokémon card scanner, but its app descriptions also discuss scanning PTCGO QR codes. Those are different tasks. Full photo recognition for ordinary physical cards is unclear. Collectors can still identify and add cards by browsing set checklists, card images, set names and card symbols.
Does Pokellector show graded card prices?
Pokellector displays estimated values for individual cards and complete sets, but grade-specific PSA, CGC and BGS pricing is unclear. Collectors who need graded values should compare the exact card, grade and grading company through another pricing service rather than treating a general estimated value as a slab price.
Does Pokellector work on Android?
Yes. Pokellector is available through Android, iOS and the web. Its broader platform support is one of its clearest advantages over iPhone-only scanners. Android users can use it for Pokémon set browsing, collection tracking, want lists, card images and estimated values without moving their collection to an Apple device.
What are the best alternatives to Pokellector?
The best choice depends on the task. TCGplayer fits multi-game marketplace pricing, PriceCharting covers historical sales and broader collectibles, Collectr emphasizes portfolio tracking, and PokeDATA offers Pokémon profit and loss tools. On iPhone, Card Value Scanner adds photo matching, PSA, CGC and BGS values, price charts and eBay sold listings.
Is Pokellector good for tracking complete sets?
Yes. Set completion is one of Pokellector's strongest uses. It offers set checklists, card images, collection progress and want lists for English and Japanese Pokémon cards. It is a better fit for checklist-driven collecting than tools centered mainly on sales data, graded values or preparing individual cards for resale.
Try the scanner on your own cards
Free on the App Store. Scan a card and compare the result with any app on this page.